Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur

4.5 ( 559 reviews )
Checking... 7:00 AM - 10:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
100 W Main St, McArthur, OH 45651, United States
+1 740-596-3300
Nestled in the heart of McArthur, Ohio, Mama Renie's Pizza is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable pizza experience. Customers rave about the thin crust pizza, particularly the pepperoni, which many deem a must-try. The vibrant atmosphere is complemented by friendly service, though some reviews do mention a slight wait for food—a small price for such deliciousness. The menu is a delightful exploration of flavors, featuring not just pizzas but tantalizing salads like the Buffalo Chicken Salad, the hearty Chef Salad, and a fresh Country Club Salad. For those craving something different, the calzones stuffed with pepperoni and mozzarella are a standout. Families will also appreciate the kid-friendly options, including classic mac and cheese and crispy chicken tenders that keep the little ones happy. Highlights from customer experiences showcase not just the remarkable taste but also the atmosphere. Notably, reviews express enthusiasm for the Buffalo Ranch Pizza and other sides, like their delectable breadsticks. Mama Renie's isn't just about food; it's a gathering spot that locals cherish. Whether you're embarking on an adventure to nearby attractions like the Moonville Tunnel or simply in search of superb pizza, Mama Renie's Pizza of McArthur beckons with a promise of satisfaction and community spirit.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Has fast service
    • Has great beer selection
    • Good for watching sport
  • Popular for
    • Popular for breakfast
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Serves coffee
    • Serves comfort food
    • Serves late-night food
    • Quick bite
    • Serves small plates
    • Serves spirits
    • Serves wine
  • Dining options
    • Serves breakfast
    • Serves brunch
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has bar on site
    • Has toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Good for groups
    • Popular with tourists
  • Planning
    • Doesn't accept reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available
    • Has kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur

Aaron Crum
Jun 3,2025
Absolutely incredible thin crust pizza. Definitely recommend the pepperoni over the cheese. Will be my go-to every time I'm in the area.
J W
May 7,2025
Food was delicious. Waitress was very friendly. Took a while to get our food.
Julie Brown
Apr 7,2025
Going here tonight. The pepperoni alone is all I can think about! Looking forward to it. And it was just as good as the pictures looked! I am not sure there are better places for pizza and wings in Southeast Ohio or possibly the state. The sandwiches I saw locals eating looked delicious as well.
JerryTerrifying
Apr 3,2025
I drug my family out to see the Moonville tunnel. My kids like ghost stories and I have been wanting to go see it for over 20 years. On the way back we stopped here for dinner and got a couple of pizzas. I thought they were great and the gal that served us was awesome. My son's been asking to go back to see the tunnel again...I want to see some more of the iron furnace ruins and I wouldn't be upset about stopping here again.
Stark
Mar 29,2025
Nice place, the food was so good we got the buffalo ranch pizza, PB pie, and bread sticks and it was some the best we've ever had. We will be back.
MaryBeth
Feb 25,2025
Fast and friendly service. Food is delicious, I recommend the gridiron burger! And the homemade pecan pie was so fresh and warm
Elaine Hawkins
Feb 22,2025
When staying at Lake Hope, we came here for breakfast and dinner. The food was delicious and the prices were amazing! Also great selection without being overwhelming. The inside also had a cozy local vibe and friendly staff. If you’re looking for a nice meal (that happens to be at a reasonable price), Mama Renie’s is the place to go!
Nick Joyce-Houghton
Feb 10,2025
We stopped at Mama Renies after a long day of hiking at Moonville and it was great. Had two kids with us, wasn't at all a problem. The pizza was awesome, really enjoyed the buffalo chicken. Prices are very reasonable. All in all a really excellent little pizza and tavern right in the heart of McArthur.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Babo Korean Bar
(405 review)
Babo Korean Bar
  • 1601 A Riverside Dr, Nashville, TN 37216, United States
Korean restaurant
+1 615-750-5847
Highlander's Grill
(526 review)
Highlander's Grill
  • 7831 W 95th St Suite A, Hickory Hills, IL 60457, United States
Restaurant
+1 708-430-9975
The Country Corner Cafe
(132 review)
The Country Corner Cafe
  • 160 S Market St, Elysburg, PA 17824, United States
breakfast restaurant
+1 570-672-2115
Mr J's
(520 review)
Mr J's
  • 1803 Kishwaukee St, Rockford, IL 61104, United States
Restaurant
+1 815-962-8009
Junction 421
(791 review)
Junction 421
  • 5104 College Rd, Wilmington, NC 28412, United States
Restaurant
+1 910-392-3490
The George Restaurant & Bar
(426 review)
The George Restaurant & Bar
  • 20 High St, Kirton in Lindsey, Gainsborough DN21 4LX, United Kingdom
restaurant
+44 1652 240270
OEB Breakfast Co.
(663 review)
OEB Breakfast Co.
  • 4132 University Ave NW, Calgary, AB T3B 6K3, Canada
restaurant
+1 825-205-9942
Poco Mexico
(125 review)
Poco Mexico
  • TX-17, Fort Davis, TX 79734, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 432-249-0536
Sierra Gold
(1231 review)
Sierra Gold
  • 6515 S Jones Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89118, United States
American restaurant
+1 702-221-4120
Surcheros - Blackshear, GA
(362 review)
Surcheros - Blackshear, GA
  • 3577 US-84, Blackshear, GA 31516, United States
Tex-Mex restaurant
+1 912-807-7827